The satirical comedies written and performed during the glory years of the ancient Athenian Democracy still pack a punch after more than 2,400 years. Athens faced many of the same issues and dilemmas we Americans face. Part of the reason for that is the fact that our founding fathers were great students of ancient Greek democracy and modeled some of our own institutions on the Athenian model.
The comedies are also much more sophisticated than modern audiences expect, featuring political views, sexual material and metatheatrical humor that seems several centuries ahead of their time. Breaking the fourth wall is not a postmodern concept like some people have convinced themselves – it was a convention established in these ancient works of comedy.
Irreverence toward any and all subjects – including the gods they worshipped – was permitted by the Athenians in the “anything goes” arena of the Theatre of Dionysus, where the comedies competed with each other at festivals, chiefly the Dionysia and the Lenaea.
TRIPHALLES – By Aristophanes. This comedy was a mythological burlesque and featured the fantastic story of the title character, a man with three penises. Mythological burlesques could be comedies that parodied the story of a specific mythological figure or could simply lampoon the grandiose approach of mythic tales. This would be done by employing the storytelling technique of a sweeping epic to tell a less-than-majestic story. Picture a modern-day grand opera about the John Holmes or John Bobbit stories and you have the idea.
For a longer review click here: https://glitternight.com/2011/09/22/at-long-last-my-ancient-greek-comedy-posts-begin/
WEALTH GODS (PLUTOI) – By Cratinus. In this satirical comedy the Titans are depicted overthrowing Zeus in a metaphor for the fall of the political leader Pericles. This was a reference either to his actual death or to the loss of his position as Strategos (Commander in Chief) depending on which year you go with for the comedy.
With Zeus/Pericles out of the way, Cratinus depicted the Titans returning Earth to the Golden Age when they ruled and all wealth was shared equally. The comedy depicted various Athenian tycoons being put on trial by the Titans, who would confiscate wealth acquired in an “unjust” way and give it to others. But just WHO gets to decide what qualifies as an “unjust” way of acquiring wealth?
For a more detailed review – https://glitternight.com/2012/05/02/ancient-greek-comedy-plutoi-wealth-gods-c-429-bce/
DEMOS-TYNDAREUS – By Polyzelus. After the fall of a short-lived oligarchy which had briefly overthrown the Athenian Democracy the Athenians were courageous enough to stay true to the principle of free speech despite the still-unsettled state of affairs in the city-state.
In this comedy Polyzelus satirized what he saw as the excessive zeal with which some of the freshly-elected leaders of the restored democracy were pursuing and prosecuting anyone suspected of having a hand in, or loyalties to, the late oligarchy. I’ve always admired this quality of the Athenians. After just having lost their freedom to an ugly band who exploited free speech to overthrow the Democracy they STILL cherished it enough to allow criticism of the leaders who had restored freedom in Athens.
It’s like how America tolerates free speech even from those who seek its destruction.
For a more detailed review – https://glitternight.com/2012/06/20/ancient-greek-comedy-polyzelus/
PYTINE (WINE-FLASK) – By Cratinus. Cratinus was known for being a big-time drinker and some of his fellow comedians often took shots at his fondness for alcohol. The Big C turned the tables on his fellow comedians and took first prize with this comedy featuring himself.
His marriage to “Comedy” was endangered by his affair with “Drunkenness”, prompting his friends and family to try to force Cratinus to stop drinking. Cratinus contended that wine enhanced his creativity and enabled him to write the brilliant comedies he was known for. “You’ll never write great poetry if all you drink is water” is the line that aptly captures the way we continue to romanticize the connections between substance abuse and creativity to this very day.
The trope of the loveable, charming drunk can be found even in this ancient comedy.
For a more detailed review – https://glitternight.com/2012/02/10/ancient-greek-comedy-pytine-423-bce/
THE KNIGHTS – By Aristophanes. This comedy was used by Aristophanes to attack his main political enemy, the demagogue Cleon. Other comedians of the time would imitate this work but Cleon’s notoriety and his past attempt to prosecute Aristophanes for one of his daring comedies add zest to this play.
The Knights proceeds from an assumption that we can still relate to today – the notion that honest candidates have no way of surviving the dishonesty and demagoguery of political campaigns, meaning that only liars and crooks wind up holding high office.
A lowly sausage-seller outdoes even Cleon at lies and campaign promises that are impossible to keep, enabling him to win an election. The Sausage Seller then reveals he is really an honest man who just posed as a demagogue to gain office, but now that he is elected he will be honest and clean up Athens.
For a more detailed review – https://glitternight.com/2012/01/16/ancient-greek-comedy-the-knights-424-b-c-e/
LYSISTRATA – By Aristophanes. This risque comedy continues to be the most widely known and frequently adapted of Aristophanes’ works. Most of his comedies were written and performed during the Peloponnesian War that pitted the Athenian Alliance against the Spartan Alliance. That war had been raging for roughly 20 years by this point, prompting the title character to organize the women of Athens and Sparta into a “sex strike”.
They plan to withhold sex from the men until they bring the war to an end. You can easily picture the nature of many of the jokes in this still-daring play. For obvious reasons this comedy has been staged and adapted to fit all manner of conflicts including the Cold War and South African Apartheid.
For a more detailed review: https://glitternight.com/2011/09/30/ancient-greek-comedy-lysistrata-c-411-bce/
DEMOI (COMMUNITIES) – By Eupolis. Along with Aristophanes and Cratinus, Eupolis was one of the Big Three of Ancient Greek Comedy. This comedy was considered his masterpiece. In Demoi Eupolis depicted four of the greatest statesmen of Athens’ storied past being brought back from the land of the dead to overcome the corruption, pettiness and incompetence of the current crop of Athenian political and military leaders.
We can still relate to this premise today because long-dead leaders retain a certain mystique that makes citizens reflect that “if only we had someone like Franklin Roosevelt (for the political left) or Ronald Reagan (for the political right) the country wouldn’t be in this sorry state.” That sentiment seems to apply no matter what the time period and wonderfully reinforces the link of our shared humanity with the ancient Athenians.
For a more detailed review: https://glitternight.com/2011/10/14/ancient-greek-comedy-demoi-c-417-bce/
THE BIRDS – By Aristophanes. More than 2,300 years before George Orwell’s Animal Farm, Aristophanes was dealing with some of the same political themes.
Athenians feeling alienated by the increasingly restrictive laws and lawsuits (seriously) of their home city have left Athens behind to start over with a new society. Part of the comedy centers around the ages-old theme of how those who seek to overthrow oppression often wind up becoming the new oppressors themselves. (Think of the 1960’s generation of American liberals who became just as oppressive as their parents’ generation had been)
Another Orwellian theme finds Aristophanes satirizing the way in which the ruling class in any society uses and corrupts language to strengthen the subjugation of the populace. The Birds even features the importance of religious and historical myths in any culture as the leaders of the new civilization conjure up an all-new cosmology to justify their own rule.
The brave new world turned old-fashioned dictatorship is called Cloud-Cuckooland, and is so notorious it was even referred to in the musical Evita.
FOR MY FULL-LENGTH LOOK AT THE BIRDS CLICK HERE
For more ancient Greek comedies click here: https://glitternight.com/ancient-greek-comedies/
© Edward Wozniak and Balladeer’s Blog 2013. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this blog’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Edward Wozniak and Balladeer’s Blog with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.
124 responses to “EIGHT ANCIENT GREEK COMEDIES WITH THEMES THAT ARE STILL RELEVANT”
Incredibly educational and entertaining! Loved The Birds and Lysistrata!
Thanks! Aristophanes is considered the best from back then!
Thanks! It will be coming down the road.
Pingback: Daniela from Costa Rica
That’s very nice of you to say those things! No, I’m not married.
Pingback: Michael J Reynolds
Thank you very much! You’ve been one of my biggest fans!
I’m an adult.
Nope. I’m not.
Pingback: SalesMan the superhero
You should read my full-length review of it then.
I’m an adult!
Pingback: Jersey Lily
Glad to do it@ Thanks!
Thanks! Plus I like to be even-handed, something the folks over at your place should try.
That’s not what your mother told me last night.
Thank you! That’s very nice of you!
Pingback: Cambo Rambo III
They are certainly deserving of that description!
Pingback: Sally the Trainer
It would be tough to choose between those two!
Pingback: The Magnate
Thanks for weighing in!
Hey, it got your mother into bed with me didn’t it?
There was a recent Broadway musical called Lysistrata Jones.
Pingback: Rowell Man
THat’s why I placed it higher.
Pingback: Mary Anne
Thanks! You said it!
They certainly were!
You said it!
Pingback: Paul From L.A.
They certainly were!
yes it is!
Pingback: Han Solo II
i’m a Constitutional Anarchist.
You said it!
Pingback: Venus Palermo
I agree! !
You said it!
u continually amazing me with the amount of content u turn out without sacrificing quality.
Thanks a lot!
Pingback: Artie D
It certainly looks that way!
Pingback: Alison V
Yep! It’s hard to go wrong with that one!
It hasn’t cooled off any these days either!
I’m an adult!
Pingback: Mary L
Thanks! I’ll have more soon!
Very well written! These are so bawdy and so political at the same time!
Thank you! I agree that these old comedies are riveting and still relevant.
Why don’t you just admit you’re a liberal?
Conservatives claim I’m a liberal and liberals claim I’m a conservative. That’s how I know I’m doing what I set out to do.
It’s truly a great and helpful piece of information. I’m happy that you simply shared this useful information with us. Please keep us up to date such as this. Thank you for sharing.
Very odd that they were that sophisticatd back then
I understand how you feel!
Lysistrata was my favorite of these.
I can certainly understand that!
Pingback: My Homepage
I loved loved LOVED your take on the Birds!
Thank you very much!
Outstanding post. Demoi would be great if it had survived in its entirety.
I know how you feel.
Demoi and Plutoi would be great to have more fragments from.
I know exactly how you feel.
Your take on The Birds and on Demoi were my favorites!
Thank you very much for saying so!
Good stuff! Nice and informative about these especially the Birds.
Thank you very much for saying so.
You should swap out the Triphalles one for something else now that the point has been made.
I will consider that.
So incredibly awesome! I never knew they wrote about such topics!
Thanks! They sure did!
So funny and so educational!
Thank you very much!
I never knew old comedies could be this relevant.
I’m always happy to spread the word.
Extremely enlightening. Balladeer’s Blog is my favorite site on the web!
The Birds sounds like the best one.
It is pretty good!
Your take on the Birds was spot on!
Your examination of the Birds is very well done.
Your full length Birds take was sensational!
Pytine is my favorite from among these.
I love your way of updating the notions behind these!
Great website. Thank you for this amazing articlescolors in spanish and english
Great site you have here but I was wondering if you knew of any forums that cover the same topics discussed in this article? I’d really like to be a part of group where I can get advice from other experienced people that share the same interest. If you have any suggestions, please let me know. Thanks!