Tag Archives: Christmas

A CHRISTMAS CAROL: A GHOST STORY (2022)

Balladeer’s Blog’s Sixteenth Annual Christmas Carol-a-Thon continues with this review of a VERY underappreciated adaptation of the Dickens classic.

A CHRISTMAS CAROL: A GHOST STORY (2022) – Let me state right at the beginning that this version of the Carol has jumped into my Top 10 favorites, yet astonishingly as of this writing there are NO user or critic reviews of the production at IMDb.

This presentation joins the many filmed stage performances of A Christmas Carol but towers over most of them. The iconic Mark Gatiss wrote the adaptation and Adam Penford directed.

To encourage as many people as possible to watch this Carol I will emphasis just once, here at the beginning, that this production truly has nearly universal appeal. I repeat, below will be the only time I cover this aspect of the work in my review, but it’s necessary here in 2025. Continue reading

13 Comments

Filed under A CHRISTMAS CAROL

SKINFLINT (1979) A COUNTRY-WESTERN CHRISTMAS CAROL

Flint (Hoyt Axton) and his lost love (Barbara Mandrell)

Flint (Hoyt Axton) and his lost love (Barbara Mandrell)

Time for another post in my annual orgy of entries on various versions of A Christmas Carol known as my Christmas Carol-a-Thon. 

SKINFLINT (1979) – Skinflint is known to me and my fellow Carol-Geeks as “the country- western version”. This made-for- tv musical is so chock- full of stars that the Country Music Hall of Fame actually offers screenings of this film every year between Thanksgiving and Christmas. I’m serious.

My late mother was, unfortunately for me when I was a teenager, a country music fan so, strange as it may seem, I actually know who the singers in this flick are. This version of the Carol is set in fictional Flint City, Tennessee, a town  dominated by the financial pull of banker Cyrus Flint, played by Hoyt Axton.

Naturally Cyrus Flint is the Scrooge stand- in and Axton is supported by plenty of other figures cast for their singing ability, not their thespian skill. Stuttering Mel Tillis plays Dennis Pritchett, the Bob Cratchit character, Lynn Anderson plays his wife and Larry Gatlin (of the Gatlin Brothers and yes, it’s hellish actually knowing things like that) portrays Flint’s nephew, called Roger instead of Fred. Continue reading

12 Comments

Filed under A CHRISTMAS CAROL

A REDNECK CHRISTMAS CAROL (1997)

Balladeer’s Blog’s Sixteenth Annual Christmas Carol-a-Thon continues with this new review.

A REDNECK CHRISTMAS CAROL (1997) – Written by John Yow & T. Stacy Helton and illustrated by David Boyd this is a reasonably funny adaptation of A Christmas Carol. Think of the type of jokes that Jeff Foxworthy was telling back when this book came out and you’ll know what to expect.

And speaking of Jeff Foxworthy, the illustrations for his You Might be a Redneck If … series of books had artwork from the same David Boyd who worked on this item. The redneck jokes in A Redneck Christmas Carol are not vicious and are told with a certain charm. 

EUBIE SCROOD, the main character of this adaptation, owns and operates Eubie’s Bait and Tackle Shop near Lake Water Moccasin. Everyone in Sand Mountain, AL considers Scrood to be cheap and mean-spirited.

Scrood’s partner Jake Marley had died a few years earlier but one and all continued to patronize the bait and tackle shop because of its incredible inventory of goods over and above just bait, lures, lines and poles. The book tells us “you could get snuff, nickel hard-boiled eggs, beer, a muffler for a Ford pick-up (years ’82 to ’89), loaf bread and motor oil all in one quick stop.” Continue reading

12 Comments

Filed under A CHRISTMAS CAROL

IT’S CHRISTMAS, CAROL! (2012)

Balladeer’s Blog’s Sixteenth Annual Christmas Carol-a-Thon continues with a review of this Hallmark Channel adaptation of the Dickens story. 

IT’S CHRISTMAS, CAROL! (2012) – Well, to borrow from another holiday, I hold these truths to be self-evident –

*** Hallmark productions in the 21st Century are mostly bland and harmless. Never too good or too bad.

*** Adaptations of A Christmas Carol that set the story in whatever their “present day” is have been going on for so long now that the state of technology and the cultural attitudes depicted provide plenty of fodder for contemplation quite independent from the core story.

*** Not providing separate, distinct natures for the Ghosts of Christmas Past, Present and Yet to Come is like coming up to bat with one or two strikes already against you. 

All that said, I won’t be able to use my usual format for my reviews of A Christmas Carol since Marley and the Christmas Ghosts are all played by one person. And it’s not a case of a comedian or a chameleon-like thespian so skilled at crafting characters that it’s a showcase for their talents. (Picture Robin Williams doing different personae for the Ghosts, for instance.)

We’re talking one lone character appearing as all four spirits with no changes to them. Fans of the more urbane and wry Carrie Fisher – as opposed to fans who only liked her as a space princess – will love It’s Christmas, Carol! Continue reading

14 Comments

Filed under A CHRISTMAS CAROL

A CHRISTIAN CAROL (2016) CHRISTMAS CAROL-A-THON 2025 CONTINUES

A Christian CarolA CHRISTIAN CAROL (2016) – Balladeer’s Blog’s 16th Annual Christmas Carol-A-Thon continues with this look at a religious-themed variation of A Christmas Carol. Directed by Stan Severance and written by Wesley T Highlander, A Christian Carol follows in the footsteps of the 1983 production The Gospel According to Scrooge.

***

That 1983 project has been reviewed previously by Balladeer’s Blog and I will say again that it is so well done that it can appeal to true-believers AND others. By comparison, this 2016 production is pretty weak and may barely even appeal to active, devout Christians. Acting, writing, special effects and singing are strictly low-level with only a few bright spots along the way.

***

Let’s take A Christian Carol beat by beat:

***

mascot sword and gun pic

BALLADEER’S BLOG

SCROOGE: The stand-in for Ebenezer Scrooge in this modern adaptation of A Christmas Carol is a woman known to us only as Carol. She’s the usual “tight-fisted hand at the grindstone” and runs a company called Rev13. GET IT? The British narrator – who sounds a bit like Robin Leach at times – tells us Carol was as dead inside as a doornail in a cute little twist on the Carol‘s opening line. Our title character has lost her Christian faith and cares only about money now.

*** 

Carol is portrayed by Brenda Roesel but comes across more like a potential mass shooter than a Scrooge-like figure. Her pathological hatred of any and every display of Christmas spirit by her employees was so heavily on the unhinged side that I actually paused to check if she was the same woman who played the end-of-her-rope madwoman in the mock Claridryl ad from years ago. (She’s not, but could have been, she’s THAT creepy.)   Continue reading

12 Comments

Filed under A CHRISTMAS CAROL

A CHRISTMAS CAROL (ITV 2000): CHRISTMAS CAROL-A-THON 2025 BEGINS

If it’s the Friday after Thanksgiving, then regular readers of Balladeer’s Blog know it’s the day when I kick off my annual Christmas Carol-A-Thon in which I review several versions of A Christmas Carol. I look at movies, television shows, radio shows and books which adapt the Dickens classic. Every year I present new reviews with a few old classics mixed in since newer readers will have missed them.

A CHRISTMAS CAROL (2000) – Christmas Carol-A-Thon 2025 begins with a new review. This ITV production from British television which presented the Scrooge figure as a loan shark coincidentally came out the same year as the Brazilian version which featured Scrooge as a drug dealer.

Neither one was a comedy, but this UK adaptation adds lighter moments here and there. A Christmas Carol runs just under 75 minutes and was made by a creative team that genuinely understands the Carol. You can tell not just from their insertion of some of the more obscure lines from the Dickens novel but by the way that even their necessary departures from Dickens to stay true to their loan shark gimmick still perfectly reflect the novel’s themes.

That is especially true of the way they almost seamlessly incorporate “repeating day” elements like in Groundhog Day and Happy Death Day

To start this review, let’s look at how the production handles the major characters: Continue reading

8 Comments

Filed under A CHRISTMAS CAROL, Forgotten Television

A CHRISTMAS CAROL IN PROSE (1960) GERMAN TELEVISION VERSION

EIN WEIHNACHTSLIED IN PROSA ODER EINE GEISTERGESCHICHTE ZUM CHRISTFEST (1960) – Christmas Carol-A-Thon 2024 comes to a close with this review of a neglected version of A Christmas Carol that aired on German Television in 1960.

A Christmas Carol in Prose or A Ghost Story for Christmas had previously been performed live in 1955 but no copies exist. Even this 1960 version was unavailable on video for decades, and the 2015 transfer to DVD is not as clear as it could be. Continue reading

28 Comments

Filed under A CHRISTMAS CAROL

EBENEZER (1998)

EbenezerBalladeer’s Blog’s Christmas Carol-A-Thon 2024 continues with the 1998 telefilm Ebenezer, the only version of the Dickens classic to feature a brothel! Well, as long as you don’t count whatever under-handed business Scrooge and Marley are running in the Alastair Sim version. (I’m kidding!)

Previously Balladeer’s Blog has reviewed The Trail to Christmas, a version of A Christmas Carol adapted to the American West of the 1800s. Ebenezer adapted the Dickens novel to the wild west of Canada in the 1800s, which adds an extra layer of novelty to this production. Casting Jack Palance as Ebenezer Scrooge was the real strength of this adaptation!  

Palance’s Scrooge is a miserly and crooked saloon owner while Bob Cratchit (Albert Schultz) is his much-abused bartender. Rick Schroder (yes, Rick Schroder) portrays gun-slinging Sam Benson, a character unique to this version and Tiny Tim is played by Joshua Silberg. Continue reading

15 Comments

Filed under A CHRISTMAS CAROL

ULTIMATE CHRISTMAS CAROL MOVIE: “INSPIRED” BY CRAFTS INSPIRE ME

Balladeer’s Blog’s Fifteenth Annual Christmas Carol-a-Thon speeds toward its conclusion! For today’s installment I’m grateful to my fellow blogger at Crafts Inspire Me for suggesting this in one of her comments here. Her blog is very enjoyable and holidayish!   

ULTIMATE CHRISTMAS CAROL MOVIE (2024) – As mentioned above, C.I.M.’s author inquired about my ultimate cast for a film adaptation of A Christmas Carol. If I could pluck actors and actresses from any production of the Carol out of the time stream I would cast the following

NOTE: I’m listing the cast from least prominent up to most prominent. 

kath soucieWAITRESS AT THE INN/ TAVERN: KATH SOUCIE – The waitress who served Scrooge his dinner at the inn/ tavern he stopped at on his way home after parting company with Bob Cratchit on Christmas Eve. She is in the Dickens novel but has no dialogue and is omitted from most versions of A Christmas Carol

   An exception is the 1997 animated version, which used the waitress as a great way to add another female character without going outside the source material. Souci as the waitress even got a song!

ghostly hearse driverGHOSTLY HEARSE DRIVER: ROY EVANS – This phantasmal character from the Dickens novel was rarely featured in screen adaptations of the Carol. Shortly after Scrooge sees Jacob Marley’s face in his door knocker, he gets a brief glimpse of this coachman driving a horsedrawn hearse.

   Roy Evans played this ghost in the 1970 Scrooge musical and actually got a line of dialogue! By default that makes him THE choice for this particular role in my opinion. Continue reading

12 Comments

Filed under A CHRISTMAS CAROL

A CHRISTMAS CAROL (1914) – ANOTHER SILENT FILM VERSION

Christmas Carol-a-Thon 2024 continues here at Balladeer’s Blog with another all-new review.

christmas carol 1914A CHRISTMAS CAROL (1914) – This British production was directed by Harold M. Shaw and runs a bit over 22 minutes. Charles Rock starred as Ebenezer Scrooge and he delivered a very good performance, diminished only by the brief running time.

Though longer than the 1901 and 1910 silent film versions of the Carol, this 1914 movie is still a big step backward from the 1913 big-screen version which ran roughly 40 minutes. One of the very few Carols to overcome being limited to just twenty-some minutes was the 1971 animated production, and Harold Shaw’s effort falls far short of that one. 

Still, there are bright spots in the 1914 version. Let’s take a look. Continue reading

12 Comments

Filed under A CHRISTMAS CAROL