Bourne Identity2. THE BOURNE IDENTITY (1980)

TIME PERIOD: Vietnam War era to the late 1970s.

Robert Ludlum’s most popular fictional creation – Jason Bourne (Real name David Webb) – has become as thoroughly overused, distorted and bastardized as James Bond or Sherlock Holmes. Ludlum himself already watered down the character’s original impact with two additional novels putting the amnesiac figure in increasingly ridiculous situations.

Since then other writers have churned out so many silly Bourne stories (ten at last count) to the point where Jason Bourne In Spaaaaace is the only avenue left unexplored. Or maybe a crossover with All My Sins Remembered. The Matt Damon movies use virtually nothing but the Jason Bourne name.

To me the bulk of the appeal of the original novel The Bourne Identity was that a reader only had to suspend disbelief just enough to accept an amnesiac figure surviving the unique set of circumstances presented in that story.  

Bourne Identity 2At the end it was accepted by all characters that David Webb/ Jason Bourne was in no condition to continue his intelligence work. Not only because of his amnesia but because he had found happiness with Marie, which made him lose the near-suicidal edge he had needed to succeed as Bourne.  

In my opinion Ludlum should have done PREQUEL stories of David Webb as Delta in the Vietnam War’s Operation: Medusa or his days pursuing Carlos as Cain/ Jason Bourne PRIOR to his amnesia.    

HERO: Since there are virtually no spoilers left about this character who has had everything but his own comic book series I will go ahead and lay out all the details of the ORIGINAL figure. This is for potential Bourne fans who associate him purely with the silly super-soldier nonsense of the movies and have avoided him because of that.

I think transferring Jason Bourne to more recent time periods robbed the story of a great deal of its unique appeal. Movies CAN work as period pieces. Studios still churn out spy flicks set during World War Two for crying out loud. There’s no reason why they can’t keep the period setting for stories dependent on the Vietnam War or late Cold War events for their full impact. 

So again … HERO: DAVID WEBB, an American scholar who specialized in ancient Vietnamese culture and spoke multiple regional languages. Webb had been serving in various diplomatic posts throughout Indochina and had a Vietnamese wife and children.

Bourne Identity 3When his wife and children were killed during a fly-by strafing from a plane of unknown national origin Webb left diplomatic work and volunteered for the top secret Operation: Medusa. (Ludlum’s fictional version of the real-life Phoenix Project.)

Under the codename Delta (later refined to Delta One), David Webb thrived in that Black Ops program. Delta proved ruthless and bloodthirsty, with his command of local languages and culture making him an irreplaceable asset against the Viet Cong, the North Vietnamese regulars and international mercenaries in the region. 

Operation: Medusa’s operatives served as assassins, torturers, guerillas and saboteurs, often locating POW camps and facilitating escapes. On one particular mission Jason Bourne, a treacherous Medusan from Australia, betrayed Delta and his team. In response Webb killed Bourne on the spot.  

After the Vietnam War David Webb pursued a teaching career back in the U.S. By now a figurative “adrenaline junkie” and still feeling empty without his wife and children, the former Delta became listless and self-destructive.

David Abbott, the Monk of American Intelligence operations and creator of Operation: Medusa, sought out Webb for a dangerous, probably suicidal deep cover assignment. The objective: flush out and capture Carlos, the (real-life) international assassin and terrorist facilitator.  

VILLAIN: Ilich Ramirez Sanchez aka Carlos the Jackal. In my view using a real-life figure such as this was a misstep on Robert Ludlum’s part. Using the real Carlos limited the story too much, since readers would know going in that Carlos would be neither killed nor captured.

Ludlum usually just does a nice pastiche of real-life figures, making it clear who they’re based on but keeping enough flexibility so that he is not bound by real-world events regarding the character’s ultimate fate. Robert could have used a name like “Charlot” (as in Charlemagne’s traitorous son) to let people know the character’s roots while preserving the crucial “Cain is for Charlie, and Delta is for Cain” sign and counter-sign.   

Robert Ludlum’s Carlos runs an enormous international organization which seemingly controls much of the killing for hire that goes on across the globe. Picture Sax Rohmer’s cult of Si-Fan Assassins crossed with Edgar Rice Burroughs’ Assassin’s Guild.

SYNOPSIS: Our hero – still unknown to the reader at the novel’s beginning – is on a mid-sized ship in the Mediterranean Sea. He is beaten, shot and left to die in the sea. He is saved and taken to an expatriate British physician in a sink-hole of a coastal town.

The hard-drinking doctor nurses him back to health (Do nurses “doctor people” back to health?) but the Patient’s memory is nearly all gone. The MD has found some microfilm buried under the amnesiac’s skin – microfilm with information about a numbered Swiss Bank Account. (This was back in the days when absolute anonymity was possible with Swiss Bank Accounts.)

For a cut of whatever amount is in that account the Doctor facilitates the Patient’s journey to Zurich to access the funds. Along the way hostile forces work against the amnesiac man but he survives because of reflexive skills at martial arts, gunplay and subterfuge. (See my review of A Man Called Noon for Louis L’Amour’s earlier, WESTERN version of this tale. Not that I’m accusing Ludlum of anything.) 

In Zurich, the Patient maneuvers his way to accessing the Swiss account, including documents which indicate his name is Jason Bourne and his account holds millions of dollars paid to him by a company called Treadstone 71. Bourne withdraws much of the money, wiring some to the drunken MD and some to banks in France.  

These actions trigger covert shockwaves from Paris to Washington D.C. Almost immediately mysterious men from various organizations pop out of the woodwork trying to kill Jason Bourne.

During one running fight our hero grabs a woman to use as reluctant cover, Canadian Government Economist Marie St-Jacques. The pair survive and in the most unconvincing  espionage story romance since Three Days of the Condor they fall in love.   

Jason and Marie make their way to France where, while undertaking the dangerous covert task of dipping into Bourne’s transferred money, they uncover more and more about his mysterious past. Circumstances make them conclude that Jason is an international assassin codenamed Cain.

SPOILERS: I use the word “spoilers” loosely since so much of this tale is already known thanks to the 1988 television mini-series and the initial Bourne movie. What Jason and Marie have uncovered is David Webb’s cover identity under which he was working to flush out Carlos.

The Monk’s plan called for a certain amount of realism so Carlos and his minions would believe that Cain was a competitor trying to move in on Carlos’ territory. When the master assassin’s people investigated “Cain’s” past, they were able to piece together a very plausible backstory for this threat to their employer’s preeminence.

Seemingly, Cain was Jason Bourne, a former operative in David Abbot’s (The Monk’s) Operation: Medusa. Using the assassin skills he had picked up as a Medusan, Bourne went into business for himself. After making a reputation in Southeast Asia after the war, Cain moved on to Europe to challenge Carlos in his back yard.  

This covert operation – codenamed Treadstone 71 – was so Top Secret most of the world’s intelligence services knew nothing about it. They, too, believed Cain was a rival assassin to Carlos. This further complicated David Webb’s undercover mission as Jason Bourne, since he was being hunted by legitimate international intelligence outfits IN ADDITION to Carlos’ network of assassins.

On the plus side for the Cain operation, we readers are told that David Webb succeeded in saving the lives of a few prominent politicians that were targeted by Carlos. In addition he killed or turned in a number of Carlos’ subordinate assassins and exposed many support operatives in Carlos’ network, including figures high up in international finance and politics.

Initially Carlos and most of the world’s intelligence agencies attributed all these actions to Cain’s attempt to destroy his rival Carlos. Gradually, however, a few men in U.S. intelligence and even Carlos himself began to suspect the truth: that Cain was a construct intended to smoke him out for capture.  

Carlos figured two could play that game. He framed David Webb/ Jason Bourne for killing many of the Treadstone 71 staff and made it look like Webb/ Bourne had sold out to Carlos. Now with Washington AND Carlos wanting “Cain” dead, David and Marie faced overwhelming odds. (Donny and Marie, however, remained completely unscathed by all this.)

In the end, Bourne and Carlos squared off against each other in a cat-and-mouse battle of wits and guns at the former headquarters of Treadstone 71: a brownstone on 71st Street in New York City. Thanks to a couple of actual decent human beings in the American intelligence community (This IS fiction!), Bourne and Marie survive, but Carlos escapes.

COMMENT: After 99% of a genuine classic of spy fiction, The Bourne Identity has to end in lame anticlimax simply because of Robert Ludlum’s decision to use a real-life figure who could not be captured or killed to end the story.

All he had to do was instead fictionalize a Carlos-like pastiche and we readers would have gotten a never to be topped finale full of action, drama and symbolism. That New York brownstone which served as Treadstone 71’s headquarters was where “Cain/ Jason Bourne” was created, so it was the perfect spot for the final showdown between Jason and his arch-enemy.

When we finally got Ludlum’s version of Carlos’ death in The Bourne Ultimatum, it was so lame and disappointing that it probably inspired Damon Lindelof’s entire career. (I’m kidding!)

Having a Carlos-manqué get killed by our hero at the end of The Bourne Identity would not have interfered with Ludlum’s sequels. The Bourne Supremacy was all about the Far East and in The Bourne Ultimatum a fictional successor to Carlos OR an old foe of David’s from his Delta or early Cain days would have been just as good a villain as the limp, lifeless Carlos that Ludlum gave us.

All that aside, the positive qualities of this novel are legion. The downside that I explored above merely knocked The Bourne Identity from number 1 to number 2 on my list of Ludlum’s top novels.




© Edward Wozniak and Balladeer’s Blog, 2017. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this blog’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Edward Wozniak and Balladeer’s Blog with appropriate and specific direction to the original content. 


Filed under opinion



  2. Have you ever thought about writing a separate blog with just book reviews?

  3. Pingback: BEST BLOG POSTS OF OCTOBER 2017 | Balladeer's Blog

  4. I believe your right. Keeping the post-Vietnam War setting for this Ludlum novel would have helped the Bourne movies.

  5. The Bourne movies left out a lot of this. Your right they should have kept the right time period.

  6. I forgot all about the Cain is for Charlie and Delta is for Cain stuff!

  7. Erwin

    You’er right. They needed to keep this story in the 70s to have the full impact.

  8. Cora

    I agree that the ending felt anticlimactic.

  9. Jose

    I never knew the novel differed so much from what they did in the movies.

  10. Wally

    I thought the Bourne movies were stupid. Your review got me to read The Bourne Identity and you are so right about how it is much better than the movies. Keeping the 1970s setting makes a big difference.

  11. Iris N

    I was disappointed in the ending too. I like your idea of using a Carlos stand-in from the very beginning.

  12. Ron

    Your Charlot idea would have made this the definitive espionage novel.

  13. Mahib

    Bourne movies should have been more like this.

  14. Lupe

    How is the miniseries?

  15. Gordon

    The similarities between Operation Medusa and the Phoenix Project never occurred to me before.

  16. Steve

    Richard Chamberlain is nobody’s Jason Bourne.

  17. Tawanna

    You make me realize there is a lot more than the surface things in Ludlum’s novels.

  18. Leslie

    Greetings from Idaho! I loved the joke about their romance being as unbelievable as the one in Three Days of the Condor.

  19. Cullen

    Delightful review! I had forgotten how detailed the novel was.

  20. Melody

    This is much deeper than the simple movies.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s