CHRISTMAS SEASON DIVERSION: THREE OPERA VERSIONS OF A CHRISTMAS CAROL

In my fifth installment of lesser-known versions of A Christmas Carol I’ll look at three opera versions of the classic Dickens tale. I’ll start off with the most lauded one- the 1982 Granada TV broadcast of the Royal Opera House’s staging of the opera by THE Thea Musgrave. Musgrave has also done the libretto and music for the celebrated operas Mary, Queen Of Scots … Harriet, The Woman Called Moses … Simon Bolivar  and most recently Pontalba in 2003. The opera is fairly faithful with the most significant changes obviously being imposed by the format. For efficiency’s sake the only scene at nephew Fred’s home is at the very end so things can close on a very festive note. Every performer except the ones playing Scrooge and the Spirit Of Christmas sing multiple roles.   This was performed in front of a live audience and runs 109 minutes.

From the year 1978 comes another televised Christmas Carol opera from the U.K. This one was first aired on Wales’ Harlech Television on  Christmas Day of that year. It is sung in Welsh, with the libretto by John Morgan and the music by Norman Kay. The one and only Sir Geraint Evans plays  Scrooge and Ryland Davies portrays Bob Cratchit. This version is short and sweet, sporting just a 55 minute running time.

Our last opera version was first aired in 1962, also in the U.K. even though the libretto and music were by American composer Edwin Coleman, who was studying in England at the time. This black and white production was later shown on PBS here in the U.S. Its debut airing in England was on December 24th, 1962. Stephen Manton sings Scrooge’s role with Trevor Anthony doubling as Marley’s Ghost and the Ghost of Christmas Present. This opera version runs 60 minutes and was critically panned at the time, but c’mon, any sincere presentation of A Christmas Carol isn’t all that bad.   

About these ads

5 Comments

Filed under A CHRISTMAS CAROL

5 responses to “CHRISTMAS SEASON DIVERSION: THREE OPERA VERSIONS OF A CHRISTMAS CAROL

  1. Michael

    I hate opera but I do think even I would enjoy these. Like you said, knowing the story is a big help!

  2. richardpercy

    I was interested to stumble across your post on Thea Musgrave’s opera – because I was in it, aged 14 as one of the carollers who sings God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen. I vaguely remember doing some carols around a Christmas tree for the cameras too, but mainly I recall singing around the streets for money between the rehearsal and performance, which earned us enough for a McDonald’s! I still have the invoice for £12.80 for my appearance on programme number 304750002. Do you know if it’s possible to get hold of a video anywhere?

  3. Andrew Dexter.

    I remember watching the one on HTV Wales on Christmas eve 1982.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s